Can you defeat a State?

“I just take it as a challenge, the louder the bomb, the more engrossed in my book I become, the more intense the shooting, the more pages I’m determined to read. And they just lose.”

That is what my teacher told me on the first day after the war when I ventured out from home for first time in twenty two days, on a visit to my university, the Islamic University of Gaza. He asked me, “How did you spend your time during the war?” I just foolishly fidgeted as I didn’t have an answer. And he said the above words. Ever since, those words have become my fundamental doctrine and precisely demarcated the essentially antagonistic relationship between me and Israel. That is to say, me as an individual, on the one hand, and Israel as a state, on the other hand. And ever since, I have mastered the game: Israel is set against me, and whatever crimes Israel commits are meant against none but me. This mindset proved influential, and functions rather psychologically. “Go on and defeat Israel” becomes your motto!

I used to say I’m never afraid of another war only because I’ve already gained an insight into how to live through it profitably. People are usually afraid of new prospects, but what are new prospects to someone like me? The intifada, the civil conflict, the siege, the war. Every time I meditate on such an inimical relationship between me and Israel, I’m quickly struck with a matter-of-fact condition of my self and a patent discrepancy between two stages of my life: before the war, and after the war. Senseless is what I’ve become. That’s why when a huge bomb strikes a nearby area and shakes the whole building, what the little kids do is carry on their game of marbles.

However, recently while I was poring over it, in a moment of complete darkness, it dawned on me how sardonically intimate our relationship is. Coming up with the actual settings of such an enlightening moment of discovery will be helpful to explain things more properly. It was something past twelve after midnight. Dark, cold, and void of the least viability. All asleep but I who is attending final exams in less than a week— although this wasn’t the real reason why I’d stayed up since my other two siblings were attending their exams as well. In any case, I fixed my study schedule in accord with our whimsical power schedule so as to avoid running into an unpleasant situation where, powerless, I would be left alone to my fiendish thoughts that would rack my mind mercilessly. This was an implicit criteria for making my schedule. I had already finished the assigned lot to be studied, and was waiting for the ensuing part of my schedule: “anything! power-on”. It was the moment I was momentarily torn out of my muse to be thrown deeper into it once again. “Power should have been turned on at 11:00, an hour ago!” I thought as I felt my heart swell with anger—such realization is what I simply tried to evade. After all, I can’t stand to be disappointed twice: one for the night power cut, and the other for two extra hours which would seem more dreadful that the past eight hours. I had already pinned my hopes on 11:00 pm as the hour when (well, I didn’t know exactly what I would be doing, but there should be power…) So I thought I perhaps can do with two more chapters of my drama book. It wasn’t out of challenge that I held the book to read. I didn’t follow that comeback philosophy. I didn’t take it as a challenge, I just felt I wanted to read. It was only then that I observed how innovatively changed I am.

The practical doctrine my teacher presented to me was but one preliminary step that would lead me eventually to a broader conceptual one I would simply call “the pliability of desire”. I recalled telling a friend of mine that there is nothing that tastes as beautiful as reading in the dark. “You just feel triumphant. Proud. Indefatigable,” I would say. Israel has made me powerful. Israel has developed in me a habit to “wait for the power cut” where I can do something useful. Israel has fomented in me love for the dark. I have made friends with darkness. I remember when I was a child, there was nothing I feared as much as darkness. Sometimes, I had to rush up the stairs at a fast pace, shutting my eyes in fear of spotting darkness. Things have changed quite considerably. I am no more kept under Israel’s thumb. As I sit in the dark, obviously working on some good stuff, the lights are suddenly turned on (Israel has turned them on). What I do following that second philosophy of mine is turn them off once again. I would turn them off following the first philosophy of my teacher as well, for what Israel really wants is draw my attention away from the “good stuff” I’m working on. In all cases, Israel loses; I win.

Mohammed Rabah Suliman
13th January


12 responses to “Can you defeat a State?

  1. Pingback: تجمع المدونين الفلسطينيين

  2. I liked it! the last paragraph, to be exact. Powerful, leaving an impression of a high spirit palestinian.
    follow up!

  3. I agree that israel created a solid generation that managed to turn israeli blows into some kind of immunity by turning the table against the occupation i.e making benefit of every racist and brutal measure the israeli occupation takes. well done Mohammed. the last para is particularly telling

    • Yes, I do agree. What Israel is doing is similar to what a father would do to “discipline” his children: he wouldn’t give them everything they need so that they don’t grow useless and spoiled. They grow men.

      • Unknowingly, though! I know yo know, but you know what? They are busy bullying and harassing us 247; they do not have the time to rethink what policy is working and what is not. It is a cliché to mention their abilities/capacities in almost every field there is, yet when it comes to their policies with the Palestinians, they suck big time. We are not quitters!

  4. Assalamu Alaykum,

    An insightful piece, Mohammed, Barak Allahu Feek for sharing!
    I just dropped by after having learned of your blog from sr. Laila El-Haddad; I presume you two have been acquainted? ( She presented at an “American Muslims for Palestine” event just two days ago here in Minnesota. Drawing to the end of her speech, she referred to your blog for more information and a deeper look into Gaza’s situation. One thing she noted–I was shocked upon hearing it–is that the people of Gaza cringe from being labeled as “victims” of a “welfare society”–that they are a people of intellect and skill (you’re proof of this, Masha’Allah), wanting nothing but self-employment, possibility and prosperity.

    Just some of her reflections…But anyways…

    This being my first visit, I’m eagerly anticipating more personal narratives from you in the days to come, Insha’Allah.

    Jazakum Allahu Khayr,
    Rania Abuisnaineh

    • Walaikum Assalam

      Thank you for your reply, Rania. It’s a pleasure. Laila is a great person; I am honored to have met and known her. Indeed, things are quite different from how people think out there. No one can reflect how we really feel and think or what we really need except us. It’s even a matter of “can the subaltern speak” and youth are starting to take things into their own hands.

      Sure I’ll be updating my blog more frequently, and I am looking forward to having more readership from the U.S. Having you around will be nice, indeed.


  5. thank you for this masterpiece m7md, I’m really wowed. I believe we, the readers, also WIN by reading you. 🙂

  6. You now have readership from Norway! Beautifully poignant piece !

  7. hello Mohammed. i was just reminded of you reading adam’s recent post on mondoweiss quoting Laila (and you) in the guardian article. i see you have mondo updates on your blog already so you’ve probably seen it.

    anyway just checking in to say hi and let you know i think about gaza all the time..also curious if you had a post up about the palestine papers.

    all in all i think the confirmation we were right all along and knew exactly what they were up to is a good thing. at least now they can’t keep pretending they have any intention of making a palestinian state while blaming they have no partner in peace. what a cheating charade they are.

    in solidarity,


    • Hi Annie. Thank you for the reply, and nice to see around. Sure, I’ll be reflecting on the Palestine Papers, I was just waiting for the whole series of revelations to come out. Indeed, the documents reveal new things and prove old presumptions, but on the whole, they are dispiriting and saddening. I will soon be updating my blog with a post on the Palestine papers.

      Thanks again,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s